The Comparison Most Buyers Need to Make
If you're not eligible for a VA or USDA loan, your choice usually comes down to FHA or conventional. Both can work with a low down payment. The right one depends mostly on your credit, how much you're putting down, and how long you plan to keep the loan.
If you have military service, also read VA vs. FHA, since VA often beats both for eligible buyers.
FHA vs. Conventional at a Glance
Here's a general comparison. Exact requirements and pricing vary by lender and change over time.
| FHA loan | Conventional loan | |
|---|---|---|
| Backed by | Federal Housing Administration | Not government-backed |
| Credit | More flexible | Rewards stronger credit with better pricing |
| Down payment | Low minimum | Low-down options available; 20% avoids PMI |
| Mortgage insurance | Upfront premium plus monthly premium; may last many years or the life of the loan | PMI with under 20% down; can usually be removed as equity grows |
| Property standards | Safety, soundness and security requirements | Appraisal still reviews condition, often less strict |
| Property types | Homes you'll live in | Primary, second homes and investment properties |
| Loan limits | County-based FHA limits | Conforming limits; jumbo above that |
General comparison only. Confirm current rules and pricing with a licensed lender.
Mortgage Insurance Is Usually the Deciding Factor
Both loans usually include mortgage insurance with a low down payment, but it works differently. FHA's monthly premium can last a long time, sometimes for the life of the loan unless you refinance. Conventional PMI is priced more on your credit and can typically be removed once you reach enough equity.
That's why buyers with strong credit often save with conventional over time, while buyers with lower credit may find FHA cheaper, at least at the start. Ask your lender to show the payment and total cost both ways.
Who FHA Tends to Fit
Buyers with credit that's still building or recovering, a smaller down payment, or a higher debt-to-income ratio. It's a common path for first-time buyers. See should I get an FHA loan? and my guide to FHA loans for first-time buyers.
Who Conventional Tends to Fit
Buyers with strong credit and steady income, buyers putting more down, buyers who want mortgage insurance that can come off, and buyers purchasing a second home or investment property. See should I get a conventional loan? and conventional loans explained.
Other Things That Can Tip the Scale
The home. A house with repair issues may be harder to buy with FHA. Your offer. In some competitive situations, sellers prefer conventional financing; see offer strategy in a competitive market. Assistance programs. Some Virginia Housing programs pair with specific loan types. Your plans. If you expect to refinance or move in a few years, the long-term mortgage insurance difference may matter less.
Run the Numbers Both Ways
The best way to decide is to have a lender quote both loans with your real credit and down payment. Compare the monthly payment, the upfront costs and the total cost over the years you expect to keep the loan. My mortgage calculator helps you test payments, and how much mortgage you'll be approved for explains how lenders look at income and debt.
For every option side by side, including VA, USDA and Virginia Housing, see what type of mortgage loan should I get? and special home loan programs in Virginia.
Let's Compare Your Options
I'm not a lender, but I work with several trusted local lenders who'll quote FHA and conventional side by side. Reach out to me and I'll connect you, then help you shop for homes that fit the loan you choose as your buyer's agent.
This article is general information, not financial advice. Loan rules, mortgage insurance, credit requirements and pricing change and vary by lender, so confirm current details and your specific options with a licensed lender.
Related articles
FHA Loans for First-Time Buyers in Hampton Roads
Lower down payments and flexible credit requirements make FHA loans a popular first-time buyer option.
Read more →
Conventional Loans Explained for First-Time Buyers
No mandatory mortgage insurance premium and often lower long-term costs — here's when a conventional loan makes sense.
Read more →
Virginia Housing Down Payment Assistance: A First-Time Buyer's Guide for Hampton Roads
Grants, second mortgages and first-time buyer loans from Virginia Housing — how they work, who qualifies and how they pair with FHA or conventional financing.
Read more →
VA Loan vs. FHA Loan in Hampton Roads: Which Is Right for You?
Down payments, mortgage insurance, funding fees, property requirements and PCS considerations, compared side by side for Hampton Roads buyers.
Read more →
How Much Mortgage Will I Be Approved For? Debt-to-Income Explained
Lenders don't approve you based on what you think you can afford. They use your debt-to-income ratio. Here's how it works, with a worked example and a simulator.
Read more →
How to Make a Competitive Offer on a House Without Overpaying
Escalation clauses, appraisal gap coverage, earnest money and contingencies explained honestly, so you can stand out in a multiple-offer situation without taking on risk you can't afford.
Read more →
